Tip O’Neill is Right

Posted by: ogenec

In the wake of last night’s contests, Washington is involved in its favorite parlor game: declaring winners and losers. Politico says the activists won. And, sure, that argument has superficial appeal: Rand Paul prevailed over McConnell’s hand-picked candidate; Blanche Lincoln is in a dogfight; and, perhaps most telling, Sestak beat Specter like a drum. Much to the chagrin of the White House.

But isn’t the real lesson — so far, little remarked upon — that “all politics is local”? To my mind, the famous Tip O’Neill statement was never more true than yesterday. Sestak beating Specter had, I think, more to do with reflexive aversion to the White House imposing Specter on the local electorate as if from on high. Even from my far-removed perch, it struck me as quite arrogant for Washington insiders to decree who the local representative should be, especially when the hand-picked candidate is not a Democrat, but a Republican seeking shelter from the Tea Party maelstrom. In that sense, the WH took a well-deserved loss. They should learn from it: Nobody appreciates having their mind made up for them by the party apparatchik.

But, elsewhere in PA, Mark Critz won the special election for Jack Murtha’s seat. And he’s no activist darling: he’s opposed to the Obama agenda, would have voted against health care, and is anti-choice. Hardly the poster boy for progressives. And yet, he won.   That is further proof to me of the “Big Tent” theory: Democrats win, and will retain their majority, when they elect Dems who represent the cultural make-up of their districts.  Whether they adhere to notions of progressive orthodoxy is, frankly, irrelevant.

So I applaud Sestak.  But I also applaud Critz, despite the fact that his views are so different from mine.  And I hope Blanche Lincoln pulls it out in AK.  The Republicans are on a party purification bender, but  I see no reason for Democrats to join them in that foolhardy endeavor.  Especially when wins like Critz’s portend that the rumors of the Dems’ death in November are, like Mark Twain’s, greatly exaggerated.

Advertisements

4 Comments

Filed under News, Politics, Pres. Barack Obama, Republicans

4 responses to “Tip O’Neill is Right

  1. ogenec

    Man, it’s been a hot minute since I wrote something!!! Hope y’all aren’t too mad at me. 🙂

  2. spirit_55z

    Thanks for sharing your perspective on the “big tent,” and reminding us of Tip O’neill’s wisdom.

  3. Mad? Who’s mad. That was a great reminder about people at the local level will elect their representatives, not Washington. And as much as I hate to say it, Mitch McConnell lost to the tea party. I don’t like Mitch but I understand he threw a lot of money at that race.

  4. Thanks for the post Ogenec~I agree, its time to stop with the purity tests for either party

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s