Health Care: A Diatribe in Three Acts– Act One

ogenic by Ogenec

There’s a lot of sturm and drang, and understandably so, about the details of the various health care bills that are circulating in Washington. Trying to keep up with the minutiae will literally make your head hurt. So maybe we should come at it from another angle. Instead of focusing on details, let’s focus on the problems the various bills are intended to solve.

The reason health-care reform is so difficult is that it presents three mutually re-enforcing problems. First, we want to expand health care to as many people as possible. Second, we want it to be very high-quality care: we want unfettered and immediate access to the best doctors, drugs, diagnostics, and procedures. Third, we want someone other than ourselves to pay for it: very few of us are willing, much less able, to pay out of pocket for the high-quality care we want.

This May Hurt So Im Going to Sedate Your Wallet

"This May Hurt So I'm Going to Sedate Your Wallet"

Hence the dilemma. It’s relatively easy to come up with a system that addresses any two of these three problems. But it’s virtually impossible to design one that adequately addresses all three. For instance, you could design a system that gives you immediate access to high-quality care and covers everybody. Let’s call this Option A. Option A already exists, in point of fact: anyone with the means to do so can go see a doctor and pay out of pocket. But since few can, the “expansion” is for naught.

Alternatively, we could fix the expansion and affordability problems by rationing care. We would only be able to consume a certain amount of health care, after which point we would either not be able to obtain extra care or we would have to pay out of pocket. Let’s call this Option B. The problem is that Option B, by rationing, sacrifices “immediate access to high-quality care.”

Finally, we could expand coverage to (nearly) everybody, and make sure the coverage is high-quality. Let’s call this Option C. The issue then becomes, who pays for it, since by definition most of the newly insured cannot?

If we understand these problems, then we’re better able to discuss the various proposals. But candor requires that we first acknowledge that we cannot have it all. There is no magic bullet that would solve all three problems identified above. No, the best we can hope for is two out of three.

Put another way, the Obama Administration can only hope to pass the “least worst” alternative. We can toss out Option A: it doesn’t expand coverage. We can also toss out Option B: other industrialized countries may be comfortable with rationing (can we come up with a less pejorative term?), but the United States certainly is not..
64000-question The $64,000 question is, then, who pays for it and how?
This issue – who pays, and at what cost? – is really the nub of the debate between public option adherents and others.

I’ll discuss the much-maligned Baucus Plan in the next installment, and the Public Option in the third.


related story: Health Bill Survives Attacks — vote by week’s end?

Full story @


**Alert** Franken offers health insurance bill

WASHINGTON, D.C. — Sen. Al Franken, D-Minn., who took office this summer, has introduced his third piece of legislation, titled the Fairness in Health Insurance Act of 2009.
The legislation would require that 90 percent of every premium dollar spent on health insurance go to actual health services. The remaining 10 percent could be used on administrative costs, advertising and profits.
Read more:

6 Comments

Filed under Free Market, Medicine, News, Uncategorized

6 responses to “Health Care: A Diatribe in Three Acts– Act One

  1. audiegrl

    Great piece Ogenec. 🙂

    You really made me think about this critically with my head, when most of the time I think about this with my heart. I hope to find a happy medium between the two. Hopefully our elected officials will follow that head/heart thinking as well.

    Watching the shenanigans yesterday afternoon, I was really angry. All I could think of was all the young people like my daughter who fell through the coverage hole, and was dropped from our insurance when she turned 23. Or the people who are working 38.5 hours a week, so their employers don’t have to provide health care.

    She won’t graduate until next year, so she is one of the 30 percent of young people aged 19-24 who go without insurance. TheLCster posted a story last week about a 22 year old uninsured college student in Ohio who didn’t go to the doctor for two weeks, and died from H1N1/Swine flu. It makes you wonder what uninsured people are going to do this fall and winter if they catch it.

    To me, this is a national health disaster waiting to happen, and some emergency provisions need to be created for people who want to get the vaccine, but cannot afford it.

    On a side note, my husband and I went to get a regular flu shot from our doctor. The doctor told us that his office could not get the flu shots, and they were trying to buy some from Walgreens.

    Wonder what is up with that? I am assuming it has something to do with more profits for Walgreens. 😉

    • ogenec

      Thanks AG. This thing has been sitting in my head for way too long. 🙂 I have to get Posts 2 and 3 out before my brain explodes!!

  2. you know, I’ve been very concerned about the sturm and drang myself. It’s out of control.

  3. betsmeier

    AG, we went to Visiting Nurses Association. Although our doctor was giving them. That’s bad when I doctor can’t get flu shots for his patients.

    Loved your article ogenec. Very informative and interesting. Makes you think about all of this. I’m actually a fan of single payer but I don’t think that
    it will happen.

  4. Pingback: The Politics Don’t Add Up « 44 Diaries

  5. It’s onerous to search out knowledgeable individuals on this topic, but you sound like you realize what you’re speaking about! Thanks

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s